Every day
Bread & Cheese
- Warm Baguettes
- Imported Cheese
Gourmet Market & Catering · Lake Ariel, PA
Your local gourmet market on Hamlin Highway
Weekly specialty sandwiches, soups from the pot, gourmet entrées to take home, warm baguettes, imported cheese and something sweet, all made by Chef Michelle Billitteri. Gluten-free options available.
- Find us727 Hamlin Hwy, Lake Ariel, PA 18436
- Hours11:00 AM – 6:00 PM, closed Tue & Wed
- Grand openingSaturday, November 14 at 11:00 AM
- Call in your order(646) 895-2222
- Chef-owned & local
- Specials rotate weekly
- Grab-and-go favorites
- Gluten-free options
The weekly blackboard
Something new on the board every week
Sandwiches, soups and entrées rotate weekly, so the menu is never quite the same twice. Here's a taste of what's been in rotation. Follow along on TikTok, or ask at the counter for this week's lineup.
Rotating weekly · on the blackboardThis Week at the Market
This week's examplesWeekly Specialty Sandwiches
Served on a warm baguette, with homemade chips
- The Figment$15Prosciutto, goat cheese, fig jam & arugula.
- The Autumn$15Turkey, Brie, sliced apples & cranberry aioli.
- The Market Press$15Chicken cutlet, mozzarella, roasted red peppers & pesto, pressed on focaccia.
- Croque Monsieur$15A French classic with ham, Swiss, Gruyère & creamy béchamel.
From the Soup Pot
Changes with the week
- Market House Soup$12Hearty chunks of beef and chicken with potatoes, carrots & signature Foodie Girl flavor.
- Creamy Butternut Squash Soup$10Finished with warming Christmas spices.
Ask about our weekly special soup!
Gourmet Favorites
Entrées to take home
- Chicken Sorrento$20Chicken cutlet layered with eggplant, prosciutto & mozzarella.
- Penne alla Mascarpone$20Penne with prosciutto in a creamy tomato and mascarpone sauce, finished with fresh basil.
- Sliced Marinated Flank Steak$25
Ask about our weekly special entrée!
Sandwiches, soups & entrées change every week.
Each specialty sandwich comes with homemade chips. Catch this week's lineup on TikTok, Facebook or Instagram, or ask at the counter: it's always written up on the blackboard in store. Specials are not printed, so what you see here is a taste of what's in rotation.
Follow along on TikTok at @michie6401.
✦ Selections will rotate; grab-and-go favorites packaged and ready to take home. ✦
Inside the market
Step inside the market
Wood-paneled walls, stocked shelves and a counter where Michelle will help you pick tonight's dinner.
Always in the case
Market favorites to take home
Alongside the weekly specials: bread and cheese, crostini kits, quiche and croissants, fresh salads, sides and desserts, packaged and ready to go.
A must try
Crostini Kits DIY$20
Crostini, freshly made ricotta cheese and your choice of bacon jam, fig jam or hot honey. A must try!
From $6
Something Sweet
Flourless chocolate cake, cannoli, Italian rainbow cake, tiramisu, cheesecake and berry yogurt parfait.
Gluten-free options are available
We get asked this a lot, so here it is plainly: yes, there are gluten-free options at the market, and gluten-free items are prepared in a separate kitchen. They change with the weekly menu, so ask at the counter which of today's items are gluten-free. If you have celiac disease or a serious allergy, please tell us before you order so Michelle can walk you through ingredients and preparation.
Catering
The market kitchen caters, too
Boutique catering for holidays, private gatherings, celebrations and special events, from intimate dinners to larger occasions. Plan it with Michelle by appointment at the market.
Small Event Catering
Birthdays, showers, micro weddings and dinner parties for up to 75 guests.
Airbnb & Vacation Catering
Arrive to labeled, ready-to-heat meals for the whole group.
Meal Prep
Scratch-made meals, portioned and labeled for the week.
Private chef · by request
In-home and vacation-rental private chef dinners are offered selectively, with limited dates.
Ask about availability
Meet Michelle
A new chapter for a Lake Ariel favorite
Born and raised in New York, Michelle Billitteri spent more than 20 years in hospitality and hotel operations before founding Foodie Girl Flavors in Lake Ariel. Private chef dinners, vacation-rental meals and intimate events built the business. The gourmet market is the next step: a small-town spot where neighbors can pick up dinner, lunch and something sweet.
“My vision is to bring something fresh and exciting to our community while preserving the close-knit, friendly feeling that makes Lake Ariel so special.”
Michelle Billitteri
A gift from the market
Gift certificates available
Treat someone to the market, catering or a private dinner. Ask in store about Foodie Girl Flavors gift certificates.
Kind words
From Michelle's Catering Guests
Food was phenomenal, excellent selection and variety on the menu. And Michelle was friendly, attentive and clearly very passionate about what she does. We will be back
Keith K.
We ordered chicken parm and ceaser salad for 20. The food was very good and delivered right to our door. highly recommend!
Ty G.
The birthday meal was great, extremely high in flavor and quality. Michelle was fantastic, warm, professional and entertaining. The leftovers were just as good for breakfast.
David Gendal
Visit the Market
Find Us on Hamlin Highway
Look for the yellow wooden sign with the Foodie Girl crest at the roadside, and the yellow building with blue trim behind it. That's us.
- Address
- 727 Hamlin Hwy
Lake Ariel, PA 18436The former Hollow Hot Dogs location - Hours
- 11:00 AM – 6:00 PM
Closed Tuesdays and Wednesdays - Grand opening
- Saturday, November 14, 2026, at 11:00 AM
- Seating
- Takeout and grab-and-go onlyThere is no seating available at the market
- Call in your order
- (646) 895-2222Call ahead to place a pickup order, or to ask about catering and gluten-free options
- foodiegirlflavors@gmail.com
Look for this sign727 Hamlin Hwy, Lake ArielCall in your order
Place a pickup order by phone, then stop by the market on Hamlin Highway to collect it. Catering inquiries are welcome too.